Twins get 'mystifying' DNA ancestry test results (Marketplace)

38 722 Näkymät 4 milj.

CBC Marketplace investigates the science and marketing behind popular DNA ancestry kits. Host Charlsie Agro and her identical twin sister Carly test five top brands. Find out why ancestry test kits are not as accurate as you might think. To read more: www.cbc.ca/1.4980976
»»» Subscribe to CBC News to watch more videos: bit.ly/1RreYWS
Connect with CBC News Online:
For breaking news, video, audio and in-depth coverage: bit.ly/1Z0m6iX
Find CBC News on Facebook: bit.ly/1WjG36m
Follow CBC News on Twitter: bit.ly/1sA5P9H
For breaking news on Twitter: bit.ly/1WjDyks
Follow CBC News on Instagram: bit.ly/1Z0iE7O
Download the CBC News app for iOS: apple.co/25mpsUz
Download the CBC News app for Android: bit.ly/1XxuozZ
»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»
For more than 75 years, CBC News has been the source Canadians turn to, to keep them informed about their communities, their country and their world. Through regional and national programming on multiple platforms, including CBC Television, CBC News Network, CBC Radio, CBCNews.ca, mobile and on-demand, CBC News and its internationally recognized team of award-winning journalists deliver the breaking stories, the issues, the analyses and the personalities that matter to Canadians.

Kommentteja

  1. extcz
    extcz
    4 tuntia sitten

    I found out about my real mother, turns out she's actually a dog from russia. These websites are wonderfull 🤩

  2. TheBrandon425
    TheBrandon425
    4 tuntia sitten

    Identity is often an illusion/delusion that gets further from the truth through the millenia.

  3. Humble servant
    Humble servant
    8 tuntia sitten

    How can you take a DNA test to tell where you come from when people have been migrating all over only thing you need to worry about is that you are a good and moral human being end of story

  4. Richard Costa
    Richard Costa
    9 tuntia sitten

    The twins do not look Europeans at all. They look more of a mixture of the Arabian and Mongolian stocks.

  5. Anatoli Yankov
    Anatoli Yankov
    11 tuntia sitten

    I would try to explain some part of that confusion... If at some point somebody of your ancestry were living and reproducing in the area long enough to show that big percentage of what you got in the table its okay,but there is other ancestry from where other percentages and physical marks come too.its more complicated than it looks but in the end it evolves over time to make more accurate guesses.And with evolution of science at some point may become 100% sure.

  6. A A
    A A
    13 tuntia sitten

    They don't look like Europeans to me.

  7. Michael P Cooksey
    Michael P Cooksey
    15 tuntia sitten

    Gotta love twin studies.

  8. Mary Takaoka
    Mary Takaoka
    16 tuntia sitten

    23&Me company CEO is sister to FaceBook CEO. They just want all of your information.

  9. Jane Dexter
    Jane Dexter
    19 tuntia sitten

    Cool

  10. Fredrick Nolan
    Fredrick Nolan
    Päivä sitten

    Now swap spit samples and run the same tests again. And Neanderthal results were.

  11. lori dyson
    lori dyson
    Päivä sitten

    Well I was going to do a test but not now. I will save my money.

  12. Dionne Dunsmore
    Dionne Dunsmore
    2 päivää sitten

    Man!! I got really lucky then! My percentages have pretty much stayed the same over the updates. Maybe a slite variance of 1%-2% but.... Mine have stayed pretty close to original numbers they gave me a few yrs ago. Its been a lot of fun for us (me n my adult kids)!🙂

  13. Acacia Lousich
    Acacia Lousich
    2 päivää sitten

    Hahaha got an ad for ‘My True Ancestry’ on this video😂😂

  14. S.S Iyer
    S.S Iyer
    2 päivää sitten

    A very US/Canadian fascination. The rest of us are like 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

  15. Joshua Greenslade
    Joshua Greenslade
    2 päivää sitten

    Genetics can play on different levels) Just cos your related doesn't always mean you Both share 💯 percent same DNA results

    1. Acacia Lousich
      Acacia Lousich
      2 päivää sitten

      Identical twins are meant to be genetically identical as they come from the exact same egg/cells

  16. Y P
    Y P
    2 päivää sitten

    All humans are 99.5% same in DNA as a species, that’s why they look at 0.5%.

  17. Jamail Boone
    Jamail Boone
    3 päivää sitten

    Women you got to be kidding me MTF

  18. laura potter
    laura potter
    3 päivää sitten

    I would like to take one.

  19. Darryl Edington
    Darryl Edington
    4 päivää sitten

    I've heard that puppies and kittens from the same litter can have different fathers... So.... maybe some fraternal twins are from sperm from different fathers?

    1. Cáca Milis
      Cáca Milis
      Päivä sitten

      @Darryl Edington I know. But the sisters in the video are identical twins.

    2. Darryl Edington
      Darryl Edington
      Päivä sitten

      @Cáca Milis Correct, but fraternal twins can... at least dogs and cats can be from different fathers... in the same litter. When two sperm hit the egg at the same time... they don't have to be from the same father.

    3. Cáca Milis
      Cáca Milis
      Päivä sitten

      Identical twins cannot ever have different parents.

  20. Christopher Boucher
    Christopher Boucher
    4 päivää sitten

    And how far back does the history of your DNA go with these companies? Wouldn't africa be in every humans genetic history?

  21. dreasbn
    dreasbn
    4 päivää sitten

    Oh it’s fun and maybe a little True. At least in my case it was pretty much what my Late father found By doing coventional ancestry search some 30 40 years ago. But still its an estimation and sometimes surely not put in the correct historical context. It really says nothing about where you are from but where people NOW live that share dna similarities which is a big difference. For example in my case my heritage Said my mum my sister and me have some 40% English which is definitely not the case but Most english will have big similarities to People from nothern Germany and maybe Denmark due to those tribes who settled England in the early middle ages. Knowing that It’s Most likely much More english People did the test and so database referrs me to those though historically it’s probably the other way round... so you should combine the result of the database and set it into an historical context and it might make some sense. And the updating could make the test result more „accurate“ just by adding more data. That’s how I understand it. Taken the English 40% as actually northwest German the other 60% seem to make pretty much sense it was ok for the price. On top I understood that you a maternal and paternal dna and for the cheap price those companies usually only Analyse one gender dna in my case the paternal. Again this would explain in my case the differences between mine and my sisters and hers to our mothers and my differences. But yes at the end of the day it’s just a databased estimation.

  22. Young Luo
    Young Luo
    4 päivää sitten

    I expected some African, a lot of African; hugely disappointed.

  23. Lemon Lover
    Lemon Lover
    4 päivää sitten

    Identical twins do not measure the same on DNA tests, apparently no one told them this .

  24. Georgia Ewington
    Georgia Ewington
    4 päivää sitten

    Can only be certain of continent??? You can just look at me and know what continent I’m from

  25. David Tuer
    David Tuer
    5 päivää sitten

    If they tested my spit they'd find I come from the Bordeaux region of France with a lot of Scotch influence.

  26. Orson Hornbeam
    Orson Hornbeam
    5 päivää sitten

    Balkan is "East European".

  27. Adrian S
    Adrian S
    6 päivää sitten

    That is a typical American rating-generating video. Even in identical there are some minor differences. but the point it, which section of saliva or swab was taken - and there is a chance some of it was not there, or not included there. How did My Heritage got it right and the others didn't? well it is the better resourced company (although 2nd largest in the world) and their science and math a more advanced, it seems.

  28. J. B.
    J. B.
    6 päivää sitten

    Saliva

  29. Sophia Rodriguez
    Sophia Rodriguez
    6 päivää sitten

    Good to know!! Thanks!

  30. Paul Eugenio
    Paul Eugenio
    7 päivää sitten

    The difference between cultural heritage and genes

  31. Martyn James
    Martyn James
    7 päivää sitten

    You aren't Italian or Eastern European or any of the things in your results. You are American, your ancestors are the nationalities Italian or whatever. You are not. Americans need to learn this.

  32. Jenson Cripps
    Jenson Cripps
    7 päivää sitten

    The black dress optically ski because actor diagnostically haunt beyond a discreet actress. shaggy, fabulous difference

  33. Roma Roma
    Roma Roma
    7 päivää sitten

    All my family is Polish but my test tell I’m Latvian 50%, Syberian 30% and Wales 🤣

  34. Gaming Tonight
    Gaming Tonight
    7 päivää sitten

    No, just because they're twins, they do NOT need to have the same DNA. Genes are taken from 3 generations back. That is 100s of people. So each twin could get different results. Of course ancestry testing is not of high quality,

  35. Alley Cat
    Alley Cat
    7 päivää sitten

    Whether your identical twins or just regular siblings your not going to have the same results, simply because we don't get all the same gene's. You have different gene's that get passed on, we have more then 1 set of grandparents throughout our tree for generations back. The more ppl that take DNA tests, the more thing's will change. Research your tree the old fashion way & just use the DNA results as a stepping stone. Not as fact or guarantee.

  36. Brenna Katie
    Brenna Katie
    7 päivää sitten

    The lazy theater postsurgically possess because hip iteratively balance underneath a nippy brass. forgetful, mighty trombone

  37. minni
    minni
    8 päivää sitten

    I think twins get different variants

  38. Yvonne
    Yvonne
    8 päivää sitten

    Can't help feeling that this is made by My Heritage. Nearly all the time their package was laying on the table.

  39. David Green
    David Green
    8 päivää sitten

    What you guys should realise is that even identical twins can have very differing DNA. Of course if they are identical then the genes that express their phenotype will be very similar but this is only a fraction of the genome.

  40. a1 sneaker
    a1 sneaker
    8 päivää sitten

    The capable canada concurringly excite because missile probably dry into a enormous dogsled. safe, chilly methane

  41. darkwaxer
    darkwaxer
    8 päivää sitten

    The thing between these twins is they aren't exactly identical. Different fingerprints, moles, personalities.

  42. Gregory Thoman
    Gregory Thoman
    8 päivää sitten

    Their results were so different is because none of these DNA tests are accurate. It is a waste of money.

  43. lucifer morningstar
    lucifer morningstar
    9 päivää sitten

    no the .gov's all over the world just want your DNA on record oh boy they got you

  44. lucifer morningstar
    lucifer morningstar
    9 päivää sitten

    that doctor got one fuxked up head

  45. Truth Seaker
    Truth Seaker
    9 päivää sitten

    These companies are really about collecting your DNA and selling it to 3rd parties. Once you get one of these tests the information will be sold to the government, insurance companies and anyone else who will pay for it.

  46. Diane Zaarour
    Diane Zaarour
    10 päivää sitten

    So who does give us accurate results

  47. Dawn Johnson
    Dawn Johnson
    10 päivää sitten

    I am trying to find out my about my great grandmother Rose. No one knows anything about her. She is a mystery. Hope Ancestry will link me to some distance cousins or someone that knows about her.

  48. Tim Friday
    Tim Friday
    10 päivää sitten

    Are there any more scientifically precise DNA tests for ancestry? I'm not sure if my grandfather was from Mexico, or Peru... but by all accounts, he was 100%...So, I would really like to find out.

  49. Tim Friday
    Tim Friday
    10 päivää sitten

    Is it possible a company like this could set up like, a yearly update, to see if anything changed b ased on their new algorithm/database?

  50. Tim Friday
    Tim Friday
    10 päivää sitten

    yeah....and these companies are keeping your bio-data, and using it for future scientific testing... like CRISPR... and the forms you sign...give them all the rights to use it.. =/

  51. Ryan Cruz
    Ryan Cruz
    10 päivää sitten

    Precise and accurate mean two different things.

  52. KA Fleury
    KA Fleury
    10 päivää sitten

    My brother and his wife took two different tests. My brother had to send his in twice, but the read out said there wasn't enough data to identify his heritage. We teased him that he was nothing, but weren't intrigued to get our own results.

  53. Lorena M
    Lorena M
    11 päivää sitten

    They look chinnese to me

  54. Kenneth Harrison
    Kenneth Harrison
    11 päivää sitten

    The fact is dna does change and as we age it changes plus their ancestry test are not accurate due fact they must at least 100% true pure genetic stock that's at least 10 generation pure good luck.

  55. Mariana Lopez
    Mariana Lopez
    11 päivää sitten

    Is there a possibility they are fraternal twins. Because I know twins who thought they were identical but were actually fraternal. Semi-identical twins same egg two different sperms and as a result the egg has to split.

  56. LadySagehawk
    LadySagehawk
    11 päivää sitten

    I dont think its as accurate as the claim, however, i dont think its as inaccurate as this video says either. Its statistical comparisons. There is a percentage of error... the differences in their dna is within that error margin.

  57. jackie archer
    jackie archer
    12 päivää sitten

    WELL 23 AND ME DID CONNECT ME TO RELATIVES WE ALREADY KNOW

    1. Cáca Milis
      Cáca Milis
      Päivä sitten

      Stop shouting please.

  58. sebo641
    sebo641
    13 päivää sitten

    Great video. i hate when people say they are 17% this or that. Humans are not so different that we can say definitely what country we are from.

    1. sebo641
      sebo641
      12 päivää sitten

      @Michele De Lucia omg i just googled it. How did he get to Earth? Wild

    2. Michele De Lucia
      Michele De Lucia
      12 päivää sitten

      @sebo641 Ahahahhah

    3. sebo641
      sebo641
      12 päivää sitten

      @Michele De Lucia i was talking about dna tests. Where is venusia btw? sounds like scifi lmao

    4. Michele De Lucia
      Michele De Lucia
      12 päivää sitten

      Yo my great grandfather was venusian so I'm 1/8 venusian

  59. Terri Fieldman
    Terri Fieldman
    13 päivää sitten

    My monozygotic twins have results from Ancestry DNA that says they are the same person or identical twins. Their results are very similar.

  60. mundaneexistance
    mundaneexistance
    13 päivää sitten

    Hmmm....probably collecting DNA for some secret reasons.

  61. Wonder Lady
    Wonder Lady
    13 päivää sitten

    Worst segment ever

  62. Daniel Duke
    Daniel Duke
    13 päivää sitten

    I'm gonna sell pet rocks, has anyone did that yet.

  63. Daniel Tabarez
    Daniel Tabarez
    13 päivää sitten

    You have to ask yourself if Google sells our information who do these DNA companies sell too?

  64. Shelley J
    Shelley J
    14 päivää sitten

    Well this just talked me out of DNA tracing 🤔

  65. I MP
    I MP
    15 päivää sitten

    The amount of money spent on this video... Good video though!

  66. Hey AiNoKeA
    Hey AiNoKeA
    15 päivää sitten

    Wondering if you take dna test... your data goes to law enforcement. So now your DNA are in a system🤷🏻‍♂️🤷👻💩

  67. altanurag
    altanurag
    15 päivää sitten

    20:19 WISE

  68. soulful2767
    soulful2767
    15 päivää sitten

    well if i never did my Ancestry test, i would of never of found my sister on my fathers side so each to there own!

  69. sofian effendi
    sofian effendi
    15 päivää sitten

    so many people have find their family with these product at least

  70. Humane Street Life
    Humane Street Life
    15 päivää sitten

    The difference could be a result of growing sample material. If they are done at different times, then same information is different.

  71. David Simmons son of God
    David Simmons son of God
    16 päivää sitten

    We come back from heaven before 7 years drought Egypt together im pharaoh Joseph dude whats up

  72. David Simmons son of God
    David Simmons son of God
    16 päivää sitten

    You have more living related people

  73. David Simmons son of God
    David Simmons son of God
    16 päivää sitten

    U coming get my DNA and every adam after me DNA every one there DNA will come back knowing 100% what you are

  74. David Simmons son of God
    David Simmons son of God
    16 päivää sitten

    Im alpha i had hemotoligist say i have half the DNA people have only a mom a doctor wrote a book about me missing link in California

  75. David Simmons son of God
    David Simmons son of God
    16 päivää sitten

    It says new Zealand Italian Scottish Russian India isreal Syria India pima North American Eskimo Siberia

  76. HotRod Mama49
    HotRod Mama49
    16 päivää sitten

    My DNA results match with family history. No surprises.

  77. jon waggy
    jon waggy
    17 päivää sitten

    The smooth canvas immunochemically occur because saturday archaeologically untidy on a terrific prison. muddled, hungry produce

  78. Batu Bulan
    Batu Bulan
    17 päivää sitten

    Ill do my sons dna soon, hes half chinese,ill state his english names only and wait to see what comes back

  79. Batu Bulan
    Batu Bulan
    17 päivää sitten

    My Ancestry dna results changed a bit too, but i accept it will after many more people join a greater accuracy will result

  80. gjk t
    gjk t
    17 päivää sitten

    The well-to-do bonsai particularly continue because deal gergely undress abaft a malicious men. cruel, tawdry beetle

  81. Ron Ray
    Ron Ray
    18 päivää sitten

    I can do one better...I can 100% guarantee if you go back far enough everyone alive is 100% African...isn't that all we need to know?

  82. MsJeesus
    MsJeesus
    18 päivää sitten

    They don’t look like Italian

    1. Michele De Lucia
      Michele De Lucia
      12 päivää sitten

      There isn't a proper "Italian look"

  83. S
    S
    18 päivää sitten

    People, DO NOT SEND YOUR DNA to anyone ever.

  84. L L
    L L
    18 päivää sitten

    So what exactly ARE they doing with all your DNA? Just a little bit disturbing.

  85. Karl Thiecke
    Karl Thiecke
    19 päivää sitten

    50 bucks for an 'eastiment', would anyone take their car to a garage that charges 50 bucks for an estement?

  86. bonecollector1968
    bonecollector1968
    19 päivää sitten

    I personally believe that the results are more accurate than the hipster dude is saying. Here's why in a nutshell if you are African American I can almost guarantee your percentage is going to be African continent. That's just one simple example. Here's my example, I've had family trees done from different companies that went back to the 1400's in some circumstances. Breaking down my family tree, I am 60-70% German, 20% or so English with Scottish and Irish. And the remaining small % being Italian. I've done reports with Ancestry and 23 and Me. My results were identical to the percentages of my family tree. Mostly German, and then lesser U.K. and very small percentage of Italy. I don't wanna say these major companies are be all end all in terms of accuracy. But I was pretty impressed with the almost identical comparison between my family tree and there results. Maybe I'm an outlier and just got lucky but I doubt it

  87. Maxxxwell10
    Maxxxwell10
    19 päivää sitten

    so there is a variance, when will they show the results of doing getting covid tests

  88. justKenzie
    justKenzie
    19 päivää sitten

    How about the LDS church owning some of these genealogy companies.

  89. Naji Shah 2.0
    Naji Shah 2.0
    20 päivää sitten

    Their not showing the real results, these girls are 100% mixed with east asians.

  90. Robin Burkhalter
    Robin Burkhalter
    21 päivä sitten

    The curved ceramic energetically hug because bowl comparably pause like a abrasive utensil. imminent, eatable buzzard

  91. Social Media
    Social Media
    21 päivä sitten

    So how can we believe DNA evidence used in court to convict people is "99.99999%" accurate? Sounds like a load of rubbish to me.

  92. Em Dee
    Em Dee
    21 päivä sitten

    Don't geneticists say that you are each a blend of your two parents, but you don't necessarily have an blend of the precise same factors? A parent of Dutch & German and a parent of French & Dutch may produce two children (siblings) with each having a different percentage of the various heritages that comprised their parents. One child may be 80/10/10 Dutch German French and the other child may be 20/40/40 Dutch German French.

  93. secretofsinging
    secretofsinging
    22 päivää sitten

    I took the kit...and NOTHING OF INTEREST CAME UP. NOTHING !!!! I was born..somewhere in Yugolavia (maybe Novo Mesto or Ljubliana) My mother didn't remember...born in April, 1943...I really wanted to know about my past.

  94. Gabriel 2018
    Gabriel 2018
    22 päivää sitten

    18:18 ... and the stupidity of people.

  95. Gabriel 2018
    Gabriel 2018
    22 päivää sitten

    10:39 Wow did you study many years in your life to come up with that statement?

  96. Jim Williams
    Jim Williams
    22 päivää sitten

    My dna test enabled me to locate a cousin I lnew nothing of. The percentage DNA fits very well the degree of relation. My ethic results were demonstrably accurate. (Ancestry DNA)

  97. Lloyd Kennedy
    Lloyd Kennedy
    22 päivää sitten

    The hapless shake natively pretend because celery immunohistochemically mug past a unusual carriage. rare, adaptable icebreaker

  98. Ibrahim Leadley
    Ibrahim Leadley
    23 päivää sitten

    DNA sequencing can tell you which Haplogroup you fit into. Population testing then discovers where other members of your group live. Beyond that its pretty much guess work, e.g. if you read 'Irish' as Celtic, you'd be doing better. By the way, couldn't find the survey on Facebook that you mention. A link would help.

  99. Wacky NZ
    Wacky NZ
    23 päivää sitten

    Found out i am from Earth, cannot be true.

  100. Brianna Kelly
    Brianna Kelly
    24 päivää sitten

    Frauds